osforlife wrote:Reynolds 1st Half: .207/.335/.385
Reynolds 2nd Half: .242/.344/.488
Reynolds SECOND half with the level of defense he's playing there now MIGHT justify an 11M contract, but we will have to play him ALL season and would have no idea when he would go into one of his protracted cold spells at the plate. Having an above league average 1B for half of a season is not an option for a contending team. His defense is just not good enough to carry that bat for three months of sub par performance.
If Reynolds would make some improvements in his range and, more importantly, start taking pitches he can't pull to the opposite field THEN IMO he would be worth an 11M contract.