| # | Name | Pos. | Comments |
| 1 | Manny Machado | SS | Potential elite shortstop, added weight might facilitate move to 3B |
| 2 | Jonathan Schoop | 2B/3B | 55 hit, 65 power; strong arm; could become avg. defender at 2B or 3B |
| 3 | Bobby Bundy | RHP | Potential plus FB/CB combo, developing change; avg. control/command |
| 4 | Dan Klein | RHP | Above avg. control of 4 average or better pitches; needs to stay healthy |
| 5 | Xavier Avery | CF | Excellent athlete, raw approach; 80 foot speed, good bat speed, boom/bust. |
| 6 | Parker Bridwell | RHP | Projectable frame; plus FB, 2 potential plus secondaries; #2/3 starter upside |
| 7 | Ryan Berry | RHP | 3 average or better pitches; good deception; injury risk; plus pitchability |
| 8 | L.J. Hoes | 2B/OF | Hitting .300+ as 21-year-old in AA, but little power; positionless at the moment |
| 9 | Clayton Schrader | RHP | Swing-and-miss stuff; plus FB/CB combo; could be in ML bullpen in 2012 |
| 10 | Trent Mummey | CF | Kid knows how to play; concussion and hammy injury slowed solid start |
| 11 | Matt Hobgood | RHP | Decreased velo & injuries have disappointed; could still become 3/4/5 starter |
| 12 | Tyler Townsend | 1B | Plus power, scary K/BB. Needs to stay healthy and improve discipline |
| 13 | Mychal Givens | SS | Plus arm and foot speed, raw in all aspects. Could end up a reliever |
| 14 | Mike Wright | RHP | Plus fastball; will be tried as a starter but likely late inning reliever |
| 15 | Ronnie Welty | OF | Rough half-season, but some pop in his bat; contact issues |
| 16 | Matt Angle | OF | 4th OFer; no pop, but speed and some on base skills. |
| 17 | Randy Henry | RHP | Good frame, GBs & some Ks out of pen. Should move quickly in 2012 if healthy |
| 18 | Eduardo Rodriguez | LHP | Projectable lefty from Venezuela. Heavy, deceptive fastball. Sleeper pick. |
| 19 | Jaime Esquivel | RHP | Some projection; sturdy right-handed frame. |
| 20 | Joe Mahoney | 1B | Crushed in ’10; Injuries halted progression; skillset may not play in MLB |
| 21 | Caleb Joseph | C | Could be a respectable back-up catcher in MLB |
| 22 | Connor Narron | 3B | Uncannily patient 19 YO, often to a fault; current 40 hit; tools to hit for power |
| 23 | Sebastian Vader | RHP | Projectable righty learning to pitch; room for growth & velo; Likely reliever |
| 24 | David Baker | RHP | Excellent starter’s frame with some room to fill; one to watch. |
| 25 | Cameron Coffey | LHP | Big lefty post-TJ surgery; rebuilding arm strength; likely reliever |
| 26 | Oliver Drake | LHP | Beware of the 24 YO successfully repeating Hi-A ball; Stuff may play in ‘pen |
| 27 | Matt Bywater | LHP | Crafty lefty could turn into #4/5 starter, mid-relief arm or LOOGY. |
| 28 | Jarret Martin | LHP | Like frame, deception; don’t like command/release; reliever at higher levels |
| 29 | Glynn Davis | OF | Need to see more; good foot/bat speed combo. Plenty of room to fill out |
| 30 | Brandon Erbe | RHP | Lost season due to another injury; could pop back up as reliever up healthy |


